“Follow Your Passion” is bad advice. {Do that} instead…

I’m on a crusade {to get rid of} these nonsensical ideas that sound logical, but {make} no sense whatsoever, and my new favorite “follow your passion”:

“{I have to} find my passion!”

Would you please kill me {at this time}? The “find your passion” idea {may be the} {sort of} insipid, meaningless argument {most regularly} {created by} B-level speakers and middle managers {who’ve} nothing specific {to provide}. It’s {exactly like} “Keep a budget!” – {a concept} that sounds logical, but {does not have any} evidence to back it up. It simply doesn’t work.

In fact, passion {is indeed} deeply embedded {inside our} culture that it’s {among} our deepest invisible scripts. But if you’re honest with yourself…how has it {exercised} {for you personally}? You claim {you have to|you should} find your passion…but has that worked {going back} {six months}? Year? 5 years?

It’s {as though} we’re just {looking forward to} our passion to fall from the sky…THEN we’ll {know very well what} {related to} our lives! Of if we make {another|just one more} {set of} what we love…suddenly, we’ll {know very well what} job {we wish}! Where {you want to} live! And what our purpose {forever} is.

Here’s my take:

People love the “passion” idea {since it} {we can} {await} a mythical day where we find this elusive passion…and then ride off {in to the} sunset on a white pony.

I prefer {another} approach: Becoming world-class at something, then letting the passion follow.

So when I heard {my pal} Cal Newport had independently {arrived at} {exactly the same} conclusion…and {actually}, he was writing {a whole} BOOK {with this} idea…I knew {I needed} {to listen to} his {undertake} it.

Cal, who recently graduated with a PhD from MIT, has unconventional {assumes} so {a lot of} {the normal} “{professional advice}” that you read.

Also, {he could be} unintentionally hilarious. When he {found} {go out} in NYC recently, I took him {to the} place that only models {just work at}. {Whenever we} sat down, I said, “Notice anything?” He looked around, confused. I pointed at {a number of the} staff, saying, “Look at them. What {can you} notice?” He stared back at me with vacant eyes. {WHEN I} explained how {EVERY ONE} OF THE STAFF WERE MODELS, he just {viewed} me. “Dude, I’m married. When I walked in here, I was noticing how nice the curtains are.”


Cal’s last guest post was {probably the most} popular {on this website}: Time management: How an MIT postdoc writes 3 books, a PhD defense, and 6+ peer-reviewed papers – and finishes by 5:30pm.

And today, to celebrate his new book, he’s written {a good} unconventional piece {on what} passion is overrated…and {the significance} of becoming {so excellent} they can’t ignore you.

Take it away, Cal.

*     *     *

Here’s {a thing that} confuses me. {Probably the most} {critical indicators} in {developing a} satisfying life is {creating a} career {you love}. {Yet}, our national conversation {with this} complicated issue is laughably simple. {We have been}, {it appears}, forced to bow down at the altar of an annoying little phrase:

“Follow your passion.”

This slogan presents an absurdly reductionist explanation for how people {find yourself} loving what they do for {a full time income}:

But {despite the fact that} {these suggestions} is simplistic, {I could} {let you know} from experience {that folks} {usually do not} appreciate any dissent. Consider, {for instance}, a piece {Not long ago i} wrote for CNN with the pithy title: “Why ‘Follow Your Passion’ is Bad Advice”

This piece quickly generated 100 comments with {an obvious} theme: People hated the title. ({Possibly the} first sign of trouble was the accompanying photo of what {is apparently} a child-eating serial-killer clown.)

Here are two {types of} the reaction I generated:

After {scanning this} article, I realized that {I will} probably keep my job {focusing on} an assembly line sorting {lamp} filaments…thanks for the advice, Cal!!

If all…people did as Cal Newport writes, we wouldn’t have Windows, Apple, Titanic and Avatar, and all programming would {be} {finished with} machine assembly language. Our society {includes a} love affair {with this particular} reductionist notion {that people} all have One True Calling, twined {inside our} DNA, waiting to be discovered. Questioning this premise, as demonstrated by the {a reaction to} my CNN piece, is interpreted as {an indicator} that you’re {quitting} altogether on {the purpose of} enjoying life:  follow your passion or {find yourself} on an assembly line!

I find this conformity ridiculous – {the same as} a world {where in fact the} only acceptable personal finance advice was: “{a cent} saved {is really a} penny earned” (a recurring nightmare of Ramit).

Reality is {more difficult}. {Not long ago i} spent {per year} researching and writing a book that rethinks common career advice. I studied {individuals who} love what they do for {a full time income}. I didn’t {inquire further} for catch phrases. Instead, I dove deep {in to the} {information on} their stories {to discover} {just how} they built passion {for his or her|because of their} careers.

Here’s what {I came across}: few {folks have} pre-existing passions {which can be} transformed {right into a} career. Furthermore, there’s little evidence that matching {employment} to {a preexisting} interest {can be an} important {way to obtain} satisfaction.

I fully embrace {the purpose of} feeling passion {for the} work. My research, however, {demonstrates|implies that} achieving this goal is {more difficult} {than} identifying your calling and {seeking} it. Put another way, {in the event that you} {fall into line} 10 {those who are} passionate about their jobs, 9 {using this} 10 {will probably} tell you {they} never {may have} predicted where {they’re} today. {The road} toward passion {is merely} more complicated {when compared to a} simple slogan like “follow your passion” allows.

So I’m fighting back.

Below {is really a} more nuanced {option to} this catch-phrase – a systematic approach {predicated on} observation and evidence:

Let’s walk through these steps…

Step 1: Identify a Target Lifestyle ({not just a} Target Job)

The {first rung on the ladder} {of the} process is identifying some general lifestyle traits that resonate with you. {Some individuals} seek extreme time affluence and autonomy {within their} schedule. Others want power, energy, and respect.

In my new book {with this} topic, {for instance}, I tell the story of two women who {finished up} loving their work, but pursued quite different target lifestyles. {The initial} {research study}, Lulu, {valuable time} affluence. She {rejected} multiple promotions during her career {in order that} she could strike {from} {her very own} as a highly-valued freelancer, taking months off between contracts {to visit} ({she’s} family in Asia) and {grab} new skills (she earned her pilot license, among other pursuits, {of these} breaks).

The other {research study}, Pardis, valued impact. Her career as a hard-charging young Harvard professor is intense, {nonetheless it} allows her to tackle a world-changing problem (she’s using sophisticated algorithms {to greatly help} cure {a few of the} world’s deadliest diseases).

Regardless of what traits resonate with you, {the main element} word {here’s} “general.” You’re not identifying {employment} or even {a business}. Instead, you’re identifying a lifestyle. {Observe that} many, {a variety of} fields {will be able to} {cause you to} this target lifestyle.

Step 2: {Look for a} Supporting Job (from Among Many Such Jobs)

The {next thing} is to {look for a} position {that may} {cause you to} your target lifestyle {beneath the} condition that – and {this is actually the} important part – you first become absurdly valuable.

This {is really a} place where {lots of people} get tripped up. The traits {define} {these kinds of} target lifestyles are rare and valuable. {In the event that you} don’t have rare and valuable skills {to provide} {in substitution for} these traits, you’re not {likely to} get them {is likely to} life.

This {is really a} key theme I encountered {over and over} {in my own} research. {In my own} book, {for instance}, I tell the story of {a} woman who dropped out of college to pursue her {imagine} starting a non-profit {that could} change people’s lives. It’s a noble sentiment, but she didn’t have any specific valuable skills {highly relevant to} {this issue}. Without valuable skills, {nobody|no-one} {will provide you with} money. {Without} money, no non-profit. When I met her, she was struggling {to create} ends meet.

This young woman had the equation backward: {you need to} become {excellent} at something valuable {before you} obtain your target lifestyle. {EASILY} had met her {per year} earlier, {I’d} have advised her {to select} {employment} where she could hone skills {that could be} {highly relevant to} successfully running {a business} of {the sort} she had {at heart}.

Here’s what’s important here: {Plenty of} jobs {often will} {cause you to} your target lifestyle, assuming you {fulfill the} value condition. {Actually}, {your present} job might {perfectly} qualify. {However},  {plenty of} jobs probably won’t {allow you to get} where you {have to be}, so, you can’t just choose something blindly.

The {a key point} here is {to lessen} your threshold. {You’re} certainly not {searching for} your “one true passion.” {You will see|You will have} many jobs {that may} {supply the} foundation {so you can get} your target lifestyle, so don’t overthink this decision.

Step 3: Cultivate a Rare and Valuable Skill

Now that you’ve identified your target lifestyle {and also have} a position {that may} {allow you to get} there, it’s {your decision} to earn it. {WHEN I} just emphasized above, the linchpin in your {search for} a compelling career {is now} excellent. I’m not {discussing} show {through to} time and do what you’re told {in due time} performance, {but rather} I’m {discussing} your employer {can do} {whatever needs doing} {to help keep} you performance.

This goal {is simple} {to comprehend} to but hard {to perform}. {A lot of people} who claim {they would like to} be excellent {find yourself} instead replying to e-mails and reading {internet marketing} blogs. Stars, {in comparison}, identify {a small amount of} specific skills {which are} demonstrably valuable {with their} field, {and} {lay out} training these skills {as an} athlete or musician.

His training often embraces the principles of deliberate practice and {isn’t} necessarily all that fun.

At a high-level, {this kind of} systematic skill development requires three steps:

Identify {the precise} skill you’re developing and a metric that {lets you know} clearly how good you currently are {regarding} this skill. As a professor, {for instance}, I {concentrate on} my {capability to} produce theoretical breakthroughs. My metric is {amount of} publication in highly-competitive peer-reviewed venues.

Stretch yourself. {An integral} factor {because of this} {design of} practice is that you push yourself beyond where you’re comfortable. You’re not {searching for a} flow state. You’re instead {searching for} the intense concentration of tackling something slightly {away from} current skills level ({an integral} distinction). {Time for} my professor example, I often force myself to dive {right into a} result or technique that I don’t yet understand and that uses mathematics I haven’t yet mastered. {This is often|This could be} really frustrating, and {I could} only {take action} for {a couple of hours} {at the same time}. But {of these} hours, my skills take immense leaps.

Seek (harsh) feedback. {The ultimate} stage {of the} {design of} practice requires that you pinpoint {wherever} you’re weak {so that you can} focus {your own future} stretching where it’s most productive. As a professor, I take the negative reviews of {might work} seriously (recall, everything {I really do} is submitted to intense peer review). I also {prefer to} {turn to} the papers that {find yourself} doing {much better than} my own {and} try to {find out} why. {EASILY} publish at a conference and another paper wins best paper, I study that paper {to discover} why {it had been} better. {I’d like} a {superior} understanding of {just what} {must be} improved, {also to} what point, {to ensure that} me {to access} a next level.

Step 4: Leverage your Value

Once you’ve {developed} rare and valuable skills {you have to|you should} then {utilize them} as leverage {to get} the traits you originally identified in your target lifestyle.

There’s {lots of|plenty of} chatter about “courage” surrounding discussions {of creating} {a far more} remarkable life: {that’s where} that courage matters. Your target lifestyle is valuable {for you personally} {however, not} necessarily valuable for {all of those other} world. Therefore, {nobody|no-one} {will make} it {possible for} {one to} make that transition. {That’s where} you might {find yourself}, {for instance}, in {a difficult} negotiation with a boss {who would like} you to {money in your|money in to your} skills for {additional money} ({and much more} hours) whereas {you would like to|you need to|you wish to} leverage it to work {from the} cabin.

If you don’t recognize the potential difficulty {of the} step, you’re {at risk of} ending up {an extremely} valuable workaholic; respected but miserable. {That’s where} it helps {to really have the} clear the picture {of one’s} target lifestyle from {Step one} 1. At every major decision point in {your job}, ask if brings you closer or farther from {addressing} your target lifestyle.

Returning to my {exemplory case of} Lulu, the freedom-loving database developer introduced above, {there have been} times in her career where it made sense {to defend myself against} more responsibility. She {were only available in} QA testing. Her first move was to automate {a lot of} the testing for {the business}, which earned her a promotion {to greatly help} roll out {this technique}. This was {an excellent} promotion {since it} helped her build her first reservoir of valuable skills. {A couple of years} later, however, she {was presented with} the opportunity {to go} {right into a} management position. She {rejected} this promotion {since it} didn’t develop any skills {which were} {highly relevant to} being to {are} {an effective} freelancer.


Feeling passion {for the} work {is really a} great goal, but identifying a passion in advance, {and} matching it to {employment}, {isn’t} a consistently replicable {method of} achieving this goal. You shouldn’t follow the advice “follow your passion.” {The higher} strategy {would be to} work backward {from the} target lifestyle, {select a} supporting job, cultivate {an art}, then leverage your value. {In the event that you} study {individuals who} {do} love their careers, you’ll {discover that} most used some variation {of the} strategy {because the} foundation {for his or her|because of their} happiness.

“Follow your passion” {is really a} nice slogan, but {we are in need of} {a lot more than} slogans: {we are in need of} systems, supported by evidence, {that truly} work. It’s {time and energy to} start {discussing} career development like adults. If we don’t, the clown {could easily get} us.

Cal Newport {is really a} writer and an assistant professor of computer science at Georgetown University. His new book, {SO EXCELLENT} They Can’t Ignore You: Why Skills Trump Passion in the {Search for} Work {YOU LIKE}, {requires a} contrarian look at popular career advice. He also runs {your blog} Study Hacks: Decoding Patterns of Success.

Do {you understand} your earning potential?

Take my earning potential quiz {and obtain} a custom report {predicated on} {your specific} strengths, {and find out} {how to begin} making {extra cash} – in {less than} {one hour}.

Start The Quiz

Leave a Comment